Public transit ballot more than about taxes

A couple of weeks ago one morning, paramedics and firefighters had trouble getting to a medical emergency at a local community centre.  The problem?  Ambulances and fire trucks had no place to park because the fire lane designated for such emergencies was cluttered with the cars of parents parking illegally to drop off their children for the facility’s daycare programs.

This is a real example of the two-way relationship everyone has with the transportation system in our daily lives.  We are all dependent on it for our freedom of mobility as well as the quality and access to the goods and services that enrich our lives.  Yet how effective that system functions depends not only on how well it is designed and run, but also on the way we all work within that system.

The public transportation system, including roads, rail, public transit, sidewalks, bike routes, and waterways, is perhaps the best example that demonstrates the everyday impact of the dichotomy of self versus public interest.  Using the community centre example, while it was convenient for one parent to occupy the fire lane to drop off their child, too many doing this congested the area, created an unwarranted risk to the community’s ability to respond to emergencies.

When it comes to the city transportation system, this line of thinking is quite consistent no matter the scale.  In the middle of the night, it may be simple to decide to use the car to get from point A to point B quickly, but quite another thing to if everyone decides to do this during rush hour.  It is very convenient personally in the former situation but quite the opposite in the latter.

However, the value of the public transportation system goes well beyond connecting people and places.  Such systems exist to extend the capability of our cities to move people and goods in a manner that expands our economic potential.  Acting individually, it would be virtually impossible to organize and finance the construction of the myriad network of roads, bridges, tunnels, traffic signals, and mass transit services that even if you don’t directly use them, they indirectly enrich your life in a variety of ways.

The Metro Vancouver region will be taking part in a mail-in referendum between March 16th and May 29th to decide whether to accept a 0.5% increase in the provincial sales tax to help finance a transportation improvement plan to be implemented over at least the next decade.  For that reason, I’ll be focusing my attention on the public transportation issue for the next few months.

To begin with, while affordability is always an issue given Metro Vancouver’s high cost of living, I will not be too concerned with it in this series of discussion, at least when it comes to addressing car-owner related counter-arguments.

Two reasons for this.  First is the drop in gas price.  One Canadian auto industry source estimated that on average, each vehicle uses over 1,800 litres of gasoline per year, meaning that each ten cent reduction in gas prices equates to $180 in annual savings.  The current 20 cent decline compared to a year ago means $360 of savings and the 50 cent fall since between late June 2014 and the end of January then equates to $900 saved per car annually.  Given that the 0.5% tax increase is estimated to cost $125 per household, it is reasonable to commit some of those savings for reinvestment into the public system.

Second is the sharp rise in truck sales, up 11% in 2014 with a 20% surge in December alone, certainly in response to the downward trend in fuel costs.  Lower gas prices will already lead to higher consumption and car use as it is, but the shift to larger less fuel efficient vehicles will unnecessarily add further congestion to our streets and environment.

I will thus be using my public interest approach with an intent, at least from a principle standpoint, to address the concerns and willingness of people to commit further investment, in both monetary and trust terms, towards our public transportation system being asked for in this ballot.  Naturally, this is a complex issue involving a wide variety of issues that I will be unable to cover given the relatively short timeframes, but I hope to use my 4DF model in upcoming posts to illustrate why the public transportation system matters and also how all of our conduct towards it contributes or deters its effectiveness.

Tagged with: , , , , ,
Posted in BC, Environment, Metro Vancouver, Public Transit, Transportation
2 comments on “Public transit ballot more than about taxes
  1. Stephen Rees says:

    Interesting – thanks for alerting me to your series. I will be following it.

    A thought occurs to me – which as usual probably drags the whole discussion off topic – but part of the problem at your community centre stems from the way we organise emergency response. The fire truck – and possibly the ambulance too – may well have not been necessary to deal with a medical emergency. The problem is that the fire brigade and ambulance service now compete on these calls. None of the equipment on the fire truck is appropriate and it is huge and cumbersome. The London Ambulance Service has been responding to medical emergencies with paramedics mounted on motorcycles. They can get through the traffic quickly and carry the sort of equipment needed to stabilize a patient and determine if they need to transported to an ER. Indeed one if these paramedics had a fascinating blog of his experiences.

    The size of firetrucks and the perceived need to accommodate them is also one of the contributing factors in development sprawl.

    And the patient is expected to pay for the ambulance, but the fire truck is “free”.


    • MillarDKits says:

      Thanks Stephen! Throw a stone in the water and watch the ripples flow, huh? Yes, I believe in efficiency as well though conditionally as you may find in my blog. Look forward to following yours as the referendum proceeds.


Leave a Reply to Stephen Rees Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: